Don’t anarchists favour chaos?

Bryan Caplan

Explore

By definition, anarchists oppose merely government, not order or society. “Liberty is the Mother, not the Daughter of Order” wrote Proudhon, and most anarchists would be inclined to agree. Normally, anarchists demand abolition of the state because they think that they have something better to offer, not out of a desire for rebellion as such. Or as Kropotkin put it:

No destruction of the existing order is possible, if at the time of the overthrow, or of the struggle leading to the overthrow, the idea of what is to take the place of what is to be destroyed is not always present in the mind. Even the theoretical criticism of the existing conditions is impossible, unless the critic has in mind a more or less distinct picture of what he would have in place of the existing state. Consciously or unconsciously, the ideal, the conception of something better is forming in the mind of everyone who criticises social institutions.

There is an anti–intellectual strain in anarchism which favours chaos and destruction as an end–in–itself. While possibly a majority among people who have called themselves anarchists, this is not a prominent strand of thought among those who have actually spent time thinking and writing about anarchist theory.

Freeblr

Discover the answers


 freeblr faq what other anarchist viewpoints are there freeblr faq what moral justifications have been offered for anarchism freeblr faq what major subdivisions may be made among anarchists freeblr faq are there different types of anarcho capitalism freeblr faq why should one consider anarchism in the first place freeblr faq have there been any historical examples of anarchist societies freeblr faq how might an anarcho capitalist society be achieved freeblr faq is anarcho capitalism the same thing as libertarianism freeblr faq are anarchists pacifists freeblr faq can anarcho capitalism work freeblr faq is anarcho capitalism utopian freeblr faq why should one consider anarcho capitalism freeblr faq isnt anarchism utopian freeblr faq dont anarchists favour the abolition of the family property religion and other social institutions besides the state freeblr faq how do anarcho capitalists compare with other anarchists freeblr faq are anarcho capitalists anti war freeblr faq what is anarchism what beliefs do anarchists share freeblr faq how would anarchists handle the public goods problem freeblr faq dont anarchists favour chaos freeblr faq who are the major anarchist thinkers freeblr faq arent anarchists terrorists freeblr faq dont anarchists assume that all people are innately virtuous freeblr faq what criticisms have been made of anarchism freeblr faq do anarcho capitalists favour chaos freeblr faq how might an anarchist society be achieved freeblr faq how would left anarchy work freeblr faq what are the major debates between anarchists what are the recurring arguments freeblr faq is anarchism the same thing as socialism freeblr faq what justifications are there for anarcho capitalism freeblr faq have there been any anarcho capitalist societies freeblr faq is anarchism the same thing as libertarianism freeblr faq how would anarcho capitalism work freeblr faq how would anarcho capitalists handle the public goods problem